Chicagos bold decision in 2016 to tax two features of the digital economy is reaping significant rewards, while the citys more conventional tax programs languished during the pandemic.
Revenue from Chicagos one-of-a-kind tax on cloud computing is about four times what it was five years ago, bringing in nearly $120 million last year, according to figures provided to Bloomberg Tax by the citys Office of Budget and Management. The citys tax on streaming entertainment has more than tripled over that period as consumers ramped up their subscriptions to services such as Netflix for video, PlayStation for gaming, and Spotify for music. The city collected more than $30 million in taxes on streaming services for the current year.
The two taxes are small slivers of the $1.5 billion in local taxes projected for the city during FY 2022, but a rare bright spot across Chicagos menu of business, hotel, restaurant, recreation, phone and utility taxes, said Laurence Msall, president of the Civic Federation, a tax and fiscal policy think tank.
The so-called cloud tax and the Netflix tax were particularly effective revenue sources for Chicago during the pandemic, when collections linked to lodging, transportation, and conventions took a nosedive. The city deserves credit, Msall said, for developing innovative tax regimes addressing digitally delivered services despite statutory limitations.
Chicagos unique approach using a lease transaction tax and amusement tax has allowed it to tap into streams of revenue that wouldnt be accessible to a municipality when you consider the sales tax laws of Illinois, Msall said.
The Chicago Department of Finance startled many six years ago when it reinterpreted two long-standing tax programs. Under Ruling #12, the city expanded the Personal Property Lease Transaction Taxpreviously imposed on automobiles, business equipment, and other leased itemsto nonpossessory computer leases. The tax extends to a wide range of computing models including platform as a service (PaaS), infrastructure as a service (IaaS), and software as a service (SaaS).
The new tax, at 5.25%, took effect in 2016. The rate ramped to 7.25% in 2020 and 9% in 2021 as the city searched for additional tax dollars.
At the same time, the department issued Amusement Tax Ruling #5. While the city had for many years applied the 9% tax to tickets for recreational activities and theatrical performances, the ruling extended the levy to amusements that are delivered electronically.
While a handful of states and localities around the country have extended their sales taxes to cloud computing and streaming, Illinois law doesnt allow that application of sales taxes. Chicago used its substantial home rule authorities to find another way through lease and amusement taxes. That makes it the only large municipality with this approach.
Creativity is paying dividends, according to data provided by Chicagos Office of Budget & Management.
The Netflix tax netted $9.4 million in 2017, its first full year of service. Revenue climbed to $28.8 million in 2020. Collections for the year ending June 30, 2021 totaled $31.2 million. In total, 47 businesses are registered to collect and remit taxes on electronically delivered amusements.
The cloud tax netted $30.5 million in 2017, its first full year of service. Revenue growth has galloped since then at annual rates of more than 40%, bringing the city $73.7 million in 2020 and $117.2 million for 2021.
Rose Tibayan, a spokeswoman for the citys Office of Budget and Management, attributed the rapid growth to the two rate increases and climbing rates of compliance. In total, 1,098 businesses are remitting taxes on leases of cloud products.
Compliance with both taxes has accelerated due in part to Chicagos active enforcement efforts and a recent statement on economic nexus.
In January the Finance Department issued a bulletin saying it expects out-of-state companies doing business in Chicago and meeting new economic presence, or nexus, standards to fully comply with the two taxes on a prospective basis, beginning July 1. The bulletin included a legal analysis of the tax programs in the context of the U.S. Supreme Courts 2018 ruling in South Dakota v. Wayfair, which permitted states to impose tax collection obligations on remote retailers based on economic activity rather than physical presence.
The guidance also outlined a safe harbor for small businesses selling entertainment and computing services in Chicago. Businesses with less than $100,000 in revenue from Chicago customers during the previous year arent expected to comply.
Its too premature to forecast the full impact of the guidance, but the overall response has been positive and some businesses have, indeed, become more willing to come into compliance after reviewing the bulletin, Tibayan said in an email.
Even as collections and compliance ramp higher, both tax programs remain controversial. The Netflix tax has been stung with litigation since it was first imposed.
In 2015 a libertarian legal advocacy group known as the Liberty Justice Center challenged the tax on constitutional grounds on behalf of Chicago users of Netflix, Hulu, and Spotify. The Entertainment Software Association filed a similar challenge in 2017, but later dropped the litigation. Chicago survived the Liberty Justice Centers challenge, winning trial court and appeals court rulings. In March 2020 the Illinois Supreme Court declined to review the appeals court ruling, which found nothing improper in Chicagos program.
Despite this precedent, tech giant Apple Inc. is pushing hard in a separate challenge to the Netflix tax in Cook County Circuit Court. The next hearing in the case is tentatively slated for December on Chicagos petition for dismissal.
Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC, the gaming division of Sony Corp., objected to the tax on streaming services, claiming it lacked nexus with the city. The company ultimately surrendered and began collecting the tax in 2018. Sony also paid the city $1.2 million under the terms of a confidential settlement.
With respect to the cloud tax, Chicago has been particularly aggressive with its audits, initially focusing on vendors and later targeting consumers of cloud services, said David Hughes, a state and local tax partner with HMB Legal Counsel.
This is not a function of the fact that we happen to be a Chicago law firm and were seeing so many Chicago lease transaction tax audits, Hughes said. I think the city is just being really aggressive in enforcing this. Weve seen it in other jurisdictions, but not to this degree.
Despite the economic nexus bulletin, significant questions remain about Chicagos position on taxes and penalties for prior years. Those issues are frequently debated during audits and the citys views are being applied inconsistently, said Samantha Breslow, a state and local tax associate at HMB.
There is some question about whether a vendor with no physical presence in the city has or had an obligation to collect prior to July of this year and if they did, how far back does that collection obligation go, she said.
Chicagos deputy corporation counsel for tax Wes Hanscom said the safe harbor in the bulletin, waiving compliance for remote vendors with less than $100,000 in revenue from Chicago customers, resolved many of the concerns voiced by taxpayers in recent years.
With a safe harbor, we were basically saying If you are under that threshold, you dont have to worry about it and we dont have to worry about it, Hanscom said.
- re:Invent recap: Amazon showcases cloud computing innovation - VentureBeat - December 3rd, 2021
- Cloud computing is changing everything about IT skills. Here's what that means for your job - ZDNet - December 3rd, 2021
- What is 'The Cloud' and How Does it Pervade Our Lives? - Scientific American - December 3rd, 2021
- Cyber Security Today, Dec. 1, 2021 - The FBI seizes alleged ransomware gang member's funds, a cloud computing security report from Google and more -... - December 3rd, 2021
- How are Organizations Doing with Cloud? - InformationWeek - December 3rd, 2021
- Amazon Way Behind Microsoft, Salesforce, and Oracle in Cloud Software - Business Insider - December 3rd, 2021
- Sidero CTO: Why multi-cloud strategies are on the rise - Siliconrepublic.com - December 3rd, 2021
- Everyone's been talking about AWS, and Google Cloud is jealous - Techradar - December 3rd, 2021
- Industrial Cyber Security Market: High Investment in Infrastructure as a Service and Cloud Computing Tools to Augment Growth During Coronavirus -... - December 3rd, 2021
- Cloud Security Alliance Issues Guidance to Help Organizations Optimize Business Outcomes When Using Cloud-native Key Management Services with External... - December 3rd, 2021
- Running business on Cloud - The Hindu - December 3rd, 2021
- EMBL-EBI Selects Google Cloud as Strategic Partner to Accelerate the Pace of Research - PRNewswire - December 3rd, 2021
- Varcoe: Amazon 'bet the right way' choosing Calgary for new data hub and tech training - Calgary Herald - December 3rd, 2021
- Joint Cloud Computing: How Can Organizations Benefit From This New Trend? - Toolbox - November 28th, 2021
- AI and Machine Learning, Cloud Computing, and 5G Will Dominate in 2022 - IBL News - November 28th, 2021
- EU companies issue formal complaint against Microsoft OneDrive Windows integration - ZDNet - November 28th, 2021
- One of the world's largest supercomputers lived for only 10 minutes - TechRadar - November 28th, 2021
- 3 Reasons to Buy Ankr - Motley Fool - November 28th, 2021
- Tencent and Green Packet firm up cloud deal - The Star Online - November 28th, 2021
- Attackers are using AWS instances to launch attacks on WordPress sites - Techradar - November 28th, 2021
- Atos and OVHcloud strengthen their partnership by leveraging Atos OneCloud Sovereign Shield - GlobeNewswire - November 28th, 2021
- Microsoft Partners With the Global Manufacturing and Industrialisation Summit To Fast-track Digital Manufacturing Through Cloud Computing - Al-Bawaba - November 28th, 2021
- Global Micro Server IC Market to Reach $6.1 Billion by 2027 - Yahoo Finance - November 28th, 2021
- Smart Cloud: What role will AI play in the evolution of cloud technology? - Global Banking And Finance Review - November 28th, 2021
- AVM Cloud VMware collaboration: Committed to customers' end-to-end cloud journeys - Malaysiakini - November 28th, 2021
- Cerebras Systems and G42 to Partner to Bring High-Performance AI Compute to the Middle East - Financial Post - November 28th, 2021
- What is Cloud Computing? | Oracle - November 24th, 2021
- The Top 10 Hottest Cloud Computing Startup Companies Of 2021 - CRN - November 24th, 2021
- An Overview of Cloud Computing Technology in the Era of Digital Transformation - Analytics Insight - November 24th, 2021
- What Is Edge Computing? Why It's Important and How It Works | eWEEK - eWeek - November 24th, 2021
- LPU Launches BTech in CSE Cloud Computing in Collaboration with Google Cloud - News18 - November 24th, 2021
- Internet of Things (IoT) Cloud Trends 2021 - Datamation - November 24th, 2021
- Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning, Cloud Computing, and 5G Will Be the Most Important Technologies in 2022, Says New IEEE Study - Dark... - November 24th, 2021
- How SOAR Helps to Hold Up Your Part of the Cloud Security Shared Responsibility Model - Security Boulevard - November 24th, 2021
- Global Virtualization Security Market Expected to Generate a Revenue of $6,986.3 Million, Growing at a Healthy CAGR of 13.6% During the Forecast... - November 24th, 2021
- Cohere partners with Google Cloud to train large language models using dedicated hardware - VentureBeat - November 24th, 2021
- 5 Ways to Improve Data Management in the Cloud - ITPro Today - November 24th, 2021
- Scalable Modular Data Centers and the Race to ROI - Data Center Frontier - November 24th, 2021
- Stocks making the biggest moves after hours: Nordstrom, Gap, VMware, HP and more - CNBC - November 24th, 2021
- Why Dream11 wants to float in the cloud - ETCIO.com - November 24th, 2021
- Beginners Guide to Cloud Computing - An Introduction ... - November 11th, 2021
- 12 Risks, Threats, & Vulnerabilities in Moving to the Cloud - November 11th, 2021
- What is Cloud Computing? | Oracle South Africa - November 11th, 2021
- Cloud Computing in Automotive Market : Qualitative And Quantitative Research Incorporating Impact Of Economic And Non-Economic Aspects | Intellias... - November 11th, 2021
- Should You Invest in the First Trust Cloud Computing ETF (SKYY)? - Yahoo Finance - November 11th, 2021
- The 3 biggest challenges of SASE in hybrid cloud environments - CSO Online - November 11th, 2021
- Microsoft to further expand cloud services in China - Chinadaily USA - November 11th, 2021
- Global Cloud Computing for Business Operations Market 2021 Supply Chain Analysis, Structure, Industry Inspection, and Forecast 2026 - Energy Siren - November 11th, 2021
- Global Cloud Computing for Business Operations Market Assessment 2021-2028| Industry Size, Share and Top Key Players: Amazon Web Services, Microsoft... - November 11th, 2021
- Cloud Computing Optical Component Market 2021: Applications, Market Assessments, Key Players Analysis, Trends, And Forecasts To 2027 - Energy Siren - November 11th, 2021
- Why a Wider Net is Now Needed to Find the Right Software Engineer - Entrepreneur - November 11th, 2021
- VMware salaries revealed: How much the cloud computing firm is paying engineers, managers, and salespeople as it navigates a future without Dell -... - November 11th, 2021
- IIT Jodhpur along with WileyNXT invites applications for its first-ever online PG Diploma with academic credits in Data Engineering and Cloud... - November 11th, 2021
- Cloud computing | Shaping Europes digital future - November 6th, 2021
- NIST Cloud Computing Program - NCCP | NIST - November 6th, 2021
- Home | Federal Cloud Computing Strategy - November 6th, 2021
- Cloud Computing Security | Trend Micro - November 6th, 2021
- The global cloud computing market size is expected to grow from USD 445.3 billion in 2021 to USD 947.3 billion by 2026, at a Compound Annual Growth... - November 6th, 2021
- Spotlight on FINRA's latest report on cloud computing in the US securities industry - Lexology - November 6th, 2021
- Microsoft rolls out new tech to connect its cloud to rivals - Yahoo Finance - November 6th, 2021
- Healthcare Cloud Computing Market Projected To Represent Strong Growth, Expanded Technology By 2021 To 2030 | Scoop News - Scoop - November 6th, 2021
- Riding the wave of edge computing growth - ITProPortal - November 6th, 2021
- Creatio Partners with Whale Cloud to Accelerate Digital Transformation for Telcos - PRNewswire - November 6th, 2021
- What is Cloud Computing? | Oracle India - November 3rd, 2021
- Cloud Computing Architecture - javatpoint - November 3rd, 2021
- 10 Future Cloud Computing Trends To Watch In 2021 - November 3rd, 2021
- Filings buzz in the power industry: 18% increase in cloud computing mentions in Q2 of 2021 - Power Technology - November 3rd, 2021
- Cloud computing spending is at a record high. But the global chip shortage could create some problems ahead - ZDNet - November 3rd, 2021
- How to go hybrid: The right recipe for mixing on-prem and cloud computing - VentureBeat - November 3rd, 2021
- Microsoft rolls out new tech to connect its cloud to rivals - Reuters - November 3rd, 2021
- Cloud computing grows but agencies lacking resources, auditor general hears - The Mandarin - November 3rd, 2021
- Why cloud bugs don't get CVEs, and why it's an issue - TechTarget - November 3rd, 2021
- Top Hybrid Cloud Computing Companies to Watch in 2021 - Analytics Insight - November 3rd, 2021
- We're still just scratching the surface of the cloud's potential - TechCrunch - November 3rd, 2021
- Cloud-fuelled European IT outsourcing spend hits record high - ComputerWeekly.com - November 3rd, 2021
- Beginner computer classes online: What can you take, and where? - ZDNet - November 3rd, 2021
- Microsoft Rides Cloud Computing Boost to Nearly Overtake Apple as Most Valuable Company | Technology News - Gadgets 360 - November 3rd, 2021
- Secrets to success with cybersecurity hiring and retention - Healthcare IT News - November 3rd, 2021
- Ekinops acquires SixSq and steps up its presence in Edge Computing - PRNewswire - November 3rd, 2021
- Alibaba launches new server chip to boost its cloud business in challenge to Amazon and Microsoft - CNBC - October 24th, 2021